California Medicare-certified home health agencies are preparing for a significant change in Medicare claims oversight. On November 2, 2026, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) announced plans to expand the Review Choice Demonstration (RCD) for Home Health Services to California, introducing additional documentation review requirements for Medicare fee-for-service claims.
The demonstration is scheduled to begin for billing periods starting on or after January 18, 2027, pending federal approval. However, agencies have a more immediate deadline: they must select their initial review option by December 16, 2026.
For administrators, clinical managers, and billing personnel, understanding the new requirements is essential to maintaining compliant documentation practices and minimizing potential reimbursement disruptions.
What Is the Review Choice Demonstration?
The Review Choice Demonstration is a CMS initiative designed to strengthen Medicare program integrity by evaluating whether home health claims meet applicable coverage, medical necessity, and billing requirements.
The program is already operating in Illinois, Ohio, Texas, North Carolina, Florida, and Oklahoma. California will become the seventh participating state.
The California expansion applies to Medicare-certified home health agencies billing Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) Jurisdiction 6, administered by Wellpoint Federal.
Importantly, RCD does not change the underlying Medicare home health benefit or establish new patient eligibility standards. Instead, it changes how agencies demonstrate compliance with existing requirements through medical record reviews.
California Agencies Must Select a Review Option
CMS has established the following schedule:
- November 16, 2026: Review selection period opens.
- December 16, 2026: Review selection period closes.
- January 18, 2027: Planned implementation for applicable billing periods, contingent on federal approval.
California agencies must initially select one of two review options.
Option 1: Pre-Claim Review
Under pre-claim review, agencies submit supporting clinical documentation to the Medicare contractor for review before submitting the final Medicare claim.
The contractor evaluates whether the submitted documentation supports Medicare coverage requirements and issues a provisional affirmation or non-affirmation decision.
A provisional affirmation indicates that the documentation reviewed supports Medicare coverage, subject to applicable claims processing requirements.
A non-affirmation indicates that the documentation did not establish the necessary coverage requirements. Agencies may correct deficiencies and resubmit documentation for another review.
An important distinction: Pre-claim review is not a requirement to obtain permission before beginning patient care. The review request must be submitted before the final claim, and agencies remain responsible for providing appropriate services.
Under CMS's November 2026 Operational Guide, California agencies must submit a separate pre-claim review request for each applicable 30-day billing period. The multiple-period submission option available in some other participating states is not currently available in California.
If pre-claim review is selected but skipped: Applicable final claims submitted without a pre-claim review decision on file are stopped for prepayment review. If payable, they are subject to a 25% payment reduction, which cannot be transferred to the beneficiary and is not appealable. This consequence applies to claims under the pre-claim review choice; it is not a penalty for properly selecting postpayment review.
Option 2: Postpayment Review
Under postpayment review, agencies submit claims through the normal billing process and receive payment before the contractor completes medical record review.
Under this choice, all claims submitted during the review cycle are pulled for postpayment review, and the contractor issues Additional Documentation Requests (ADRs).
Agencies must then submit clinical documentation demonstrating that the patient qualified for Medicare-covered home health services and that the billed care was medically necessary.
If the documentation does not support coverage, claims may be denied after review, resulting in overpayment determinations and potential recoupment.
CMS has specifically stated that agencies that do not make an initial review selection will automatically be assigned to postpayment review.
Neither review pathway eliminates the need for complete, accurate, and timely clinical documentation.
What Are Additional Documentation Requests?
An Additional Documentation Request is issued when a Medicare reviewer needs medical records or other supporting information to determine whether a claim meets Medicare requirements.
An ADR is not automatically an indication of fraud, inappropriate care, or regulatory noncompliance. It is a documentation review process.
However, failure to respond adequately can have financial consequences.
For ADRs issued by Medicare Administrative Contractors, the standard response period is generally 45 calendar days. Requests issued by Unified Program Integrity Contractors (UPICs) generally have a 30-calendar-day response period.
Agencies should always verify the deadline identified in the specific request.
What Documentation Will Medicare Review?
CMS's home health review guidance emphasizes documentation supporting the patient's eligibility and the medical necessity of services.
Agencies should be prepared to demonstrate:
Homebound status: Clinical evidence showing that the patient meets Medicare's homebound criteria, including the functional limitations and circumstances supporting that determination.
Need for skilled services: Documentation establishing why skilled nursing, therapy, or another qualifying skilled service is required.
Face-to-face encounter: Evidence of a qualifying encounter occurring within the applicable Medicare timeframe and related to the primary reason for home health services.
Certification and plan of care: Complete, appropriately authorized documentation supporting the services ordered and provided.
Ongoing clinical documentation: Assessments, visit notes, progress documentation, and other relevant records demonstrating the patient's condition, services furnished, and continued need for care.
A physician or practitioner's order alone does not necessarily establish that every service billed meets Medicare coverage criteria. The clinical documentation must support the services provided.
Agencies May Qualify for Reduced Review
The initial RCD review cycle lasts six months.
According to CMS's November 2026 Operational Guide, agencies achieving an affirmation or claim approval rate of at least 90%, based on a minimum of 10 reviewed requests or claims, may qualify for additional review choices in subsequent cycles.
Those options include selective postpayment review and spot-check review.
Agencies that do not meet the threshold must continue selecting from the initial review options.
This makes the quality of documentation submitted during the first six months particularly important.
What Should California Home Health Agencies Do Now?
Agencies should begin preparing before the demonstration takes effect.
Recommended actions include:
- Select a review option before December 16, 2026. Evaluate current documentation workflows, billing processes, and administrative resources before making the selection.
- Conduct an internal clinical record audit. Review a representative sample of admissions and ongoing patient records for Medicare eligibility, certification, medical necessity, and documentation completeness.
- Evaluate physician and practitioner documentation. Establish processes for obtaining necessary face-to-face records, orders, certifications, and supporting clinical information.
- Train clinical and billing personnel. Staff should understand the selected review pathway, documentation submission procedures, response requirements, and applicable deadlines.
- Establish an ADR management process. Assign responsibility for monitoring requests, obtaining supporting documentation, tracking submission deadlines, and maintaining evidence of timely responses.
- Review applicable policies and procedures. Ensure the agency's written processes accurately reflect how Medicare documentation, clinical review, billing, and corrective actions are managed.
- Monitor review results. Track non-affirmations, denials, documentation deficiencies, and patterns requiring corrective action.
Agencies selecting pre-claim review should also establish procedures to track requests, review decisions, resubmissions, and Unique Tracking Numbers (UTNs).
Preparing Before Implementation
The most effective preparation begins before the first claim is reviewed. With the selection period ending December 16, agencies should evaluate their options now and coordinate clinical documentation, billing, and compliance workflows before implementation.
Related reading: CMS Extends Hospice and Home Health Medicare Moratorium.